Header Ads Widget

Latest Updates


What is the difference between exhibition of documents and marking of documents IN EVIDENCE?

Not much of a difference. Frankly, there has been much ado about nothing.

What is the difference between exhibition of documents

‘Exhibit’ number is usually held to be legally admissible:

The general belief is that a document which is given an ‘Exhibit’ number is usually held to be legally admissible. For instance, original documents are given the nomenclature of ‘Exhibits’ by the Court and accepted in evidence as ‘Exhibit A’, ‘Exhibit B’ and so on.

Also Read: Can a property be gifted by a donor to two daughters and one son out of three sons is it voidable in the court of law

However, it needs to be remembered that, this – by itself, does not amount to proof of a document. EVERY DOCUMENT HAS TO BE PROVED IN ACCORDANCE OF LAW – WHETHER IT IS MARKED AS AN EXHIBIT OR A MARK.

A document exhibited in evidence may still be taken not to be proved and, therefore, the court may eschew it from consideration. Marking – similarly, also pertains to simply giving a nomenclature to a document for the purposes of identification. In practice, it is believed (albeit erroneously) that documents which are photocopies or otherwise ‘objected-to’ during recording of evidence (on whatever ground) are to be ‘marked’ and not ‘exhibited’.

Document is ‘marked’ does not make it inadmissible:

However, there is little legal sanction or meaning to it. Merely because a document is ‘marked’ does not make it inadmissible. The question of admissibility and proof would be decided by the court separately.

Also Read: Can a Judge or Magistrate deliver Judgement in the absence of accused under Section 138 of NI Act

Conversely, just because a document is ‘exhibited’ does not mean that it is conclusively taken to be proved or decided to be ‘admissible’.

Procedure to Marking as an Exhibit:

All in all, marking something as an ‘exhibit’ (Eg : Exhibit PW1/A, PW1/B, and so on) or ‘marking’ it (Eg : Mark A, Mark B, and so), hardly makes any difference as in either case:–

Also Read: A man killing his wife by injecting cyanide solution into her drip bottle while she was undergoing treatment

⇛i) document has to be proved in accordance with law;

⇛ii) Its admissibility – still – has to be established.

Much ado about nothing, right?
For clarity, read Justice Lahoti’s brilliant exposition on this in Sudir Engineering Company vs Nitco Roadways Ltd, 1995 (34) DRJ 86,

This article written by Legal AdvisoryTeam

Free Last Ten year All India Bar Examination Practice Mock Test Series

Disclaimer: We try to ensure that the information we post on Legal Advisory is accurate. However, despite of our best efforts, some of the content may contain errors. You can trust us, but legal advisory is not liable for any error

Thank You

You can connect with us:

Trending Articles:

⇛ 1 - Uttar Pradesh Population Control Draft Bill, 2021
⇛ 2 - Can a Judge or Magistrate deliver Judgement in the absence of accused under Section 138 of NI Act
⇛ 3 - How to Apply for Non -Availability of Birth Certificate (NABC) in India
⇛ 4 - Whether restaurants fall under the category of industry or not know with relevant case laws
⇛ 5 - Publication of marriage notice under special marriage act is violate of right to privacy Allahabad High Court
⇛ 6 - Address me as "Sir", not "My Lord" or "Lordship", urges Calcutta High Court Chief Justice Thottathil B Radhakrishnan
⇛ 7 - Whether the Lease rent covered under the operational creditor or not
⇛ 8 - Legal Procedures for Suing An Employer For Harassment Or Discrimination to Employee In India
⇛ 9 - 10 Civil Rights & Legal Rights Every Indian Citizen Should Be know
⇛ 10 - Are Indian Muslims using secularism for their profit making ?
⇛ 11 - Types of guardianship in Mohammedan (Muslim) law of Minor child or its conclusion
⇛ 12 - History of Curative Petition and Its Scope In India and in Reference To Nirbhaya Case and Ayodhya Case.
⇛ 13 - Maharashtra Anti-Corruption Bureau arrests a Local Court Judge in Bribery Case.
⇛ 14 - Lok Sabha passes constitution one hundred and twenty seventh Amendment bill to restore state rights on OBC list
⇛ 15 - Pradhan Mantri Ujjwala Yojana 2.0 (PMUY) 2021 (Free Connection)

Post a Comment


10 Civil and Legal Rights Every Citizen of the Nation Should Be know